Comparative evaluation of simulators for practising fluoroscopy-guided renal pelvic puncture
Introduction. The skill of puncture of the kidney pelvicalyceal system is one of the basic urological skills, as it is used for various surgical interventions. There are different training models, from laboratory animals to virtual reality simulators.Objective. To evaluate a non-biological model of...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | Russian |
| Published: |
Ministry of Health of Russian Federation, Rostov State Medical University, State Budget Educational Institute of Higher Professional Education
2023-10-01
|
| Series: | Вестник урологии |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://www.urovest.ru/jour/article/view/753 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1839577564250636288 |
|---|---|
| author | N. K. Gadzhiev D. S. Gorelov A. A. Mishchenko V. P. Britov R. R. Kharchilava E. F. Sharafutdinov S. B. Petrov D. D. Shkarupa |
| author_facet | N. K. Gadzhiev D. S. Gorelov A. A. Mishchenko V. P. Britov R. R. Kharchilava E. F. Sharafutdinov S. B. Petrov D. D. Shkarupa |
| author_sort | N. K. Gadzhiev |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Introduction. The skill of puncture of the kidney pelvicalyceal system is one of the basic urological skills, as it is used for various surgical interventions. There are different training models, from laboratory animals to virtual reality simulators.Objective. To evaluate a non-biological model of the pelvicalyceal system puncture simulator UroATOM (“Alfa-Rhythm”, Russian Federation) and to compare it with a virtual reality simulator PERC MentorTM (“Simbionix”, Beit Golan, Israel).Materials & methods. The results of fluoroscopic guided puncture training were analyzed among 50 physicians. The specialists were divided into two equal groups by experience: group 1 — beginners, group 2 — experienced urologists. In phase 1, both simulators were evaluated by the physicians using Likert questionnaires. In phase 2, the puncture results in beginners were evaluated before and after the UroATOM simulator practise.Results. Comparing the indices of both simulators showed that UroATOM was rated as more convenient to use (p = 0.0001) and cheaper (p < 0.0001). The analysis of the puncture performance by "beginners" before and after UroATOM training revealed a statistically significant improvement in the performance. The puncture time index improved by 79 seconds. The index of fluoroscopy duration decreased by 40.9 seconds. The number of puncture attempts decreased by 1.4 times. The amount of contrast decreased by 5.4 ml.Conclusions. The UroATOM simulator is effective for training young specialists in fluoroscopy-guided renal cavity puncture. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-9ab5382d2d2b404db87d9c18da3edb09 |
| institution | Matheson Library |
| issn | 2308-6424 |
| language | Russian |
| publishDate | 2023-10-01 |
| publisher | Ministry of Health of Russian Federation, Rostov State Medical University, State Budget Educational Institute of Higher Professional Education |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Вестник урологии |
| spelling | doaj-art-9ab5382d2d2b404db87d9c18da3edb092025-08-04T12:51:16ZrusMinistry of Health of Russian Federation, Rostov State Medical University, State Budget Educational Institute of Higher Professional EducationВестник урологии2308-64242023-10-01113233410.21886/2308-6424-2023-11-3-23-34463Comparative evaluation of simulators for practising fluoroscopy-guided renal pelvic punctureN. K. Gadzhiev0D. S. Gorelov1A. A. Mishchenko2V. P. Britov3R. R. Kharchilava4E. F. Sharafutdinov5S. B. Petrov6D. D. Shkarupa7Pirogov Clinic of Advanced Medical Technologies (SPSU Hospital), St. Petersburg State UniversityPavlov First State Medical University of St. PetersburgPavlov First State Medical University of St. PetersburgSt. Petersburg State Institute of Technology (Technical University)I.M. Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University (Sechenov University)St. Petersburg State Pediatric MedicalPavlov First State Medical University of St. PetersburgPirogov Clinic of Advanced Medical Technologies (SPSU Hospital), St. Petersburg State UniversityIntroduction. The skill of puncture of the kidney pelvicalyceal system is one of the basic urological skills, as it is used for various surgical interventions. There are different training models, from laboratory animals to virtual reality simulators.Objective. To evaluate a non-biological model of the pelvicalyceal system puncture simulator UroATOM (“Alfa-Rhythm”, Russian Federation) and to compare it with a virtual reality simulator PERC MentorTM (“Simbionix”, Beit Golan, Israel).Materials & methods. The results of fluoroscopic guided puncture training were analyzed among 50 physicians. The specialists were divided into two equal groups by experience: group 1 — beginners, group 2 — experienced urologists. In phase 1, both simulators were evaluated by the physicians using Likert questionnaires. In phase 2, the puncture results in beginners were evaluated before and after the UroATOM simulator practise.Results. Comparing the indices of both simulators showed that UroATOM was rated as more convenient to use (p = 0.0001) and cheaper (p < 0.0001). The analysis of the puncture performance by "beginners" before and after UroATOM training revealed a statistically significant improvement in the performance. The puncture time index improved by 79 seconds. The index of fluoroscopy duration decreased by 40.9 seconds. The number of puncture attempts decreased by 1.4 times. The amount of contrast decreased by 5.4 ml.Conclusions. The UroATOM simulator is effective for training young specialists in fluoroscopy-guided renal cavity puncture.https://www.urovest.ru/jour/article/view/753kidneyssimulatorpercutaneous accesstrainingpuncturefluoroscopy |
| spellingShingle | N. K. Gadzhiev D. S. Gorelov A. A. Mishchenko V. P. Britov R. R. Kharchilava E. F. Sharafutdinov S. B. Petrov D. D. Shkarupa Comparative evaluation of simulators for practising fluoroscopy-guided renal pelvic puncture Вестник урологии kidneys simulator percutaneous access training puncture fluoroscopy |
| title | Comparative evaluation of simulators for practising fluoroscopy-guided renal pelvic puncture |
| title_full | Comparative evaluation of simulators for practising fluoroscopy-guided renal pelvic puncture |
| title_fullStr | Comparative evaluation of simulators for practising fluoroscopy-guided renal pelvic puncture |
| title_full_unstemmed | Comparative evaluation of simulators for practising fluoroscopy-guided renal pelvic puncture |
| title_short | Comparative evaluation of simulators for practising fluoroscopy-guided renal pelvic puncture |
| title_sort | comparative evaluation of simulators for practising fluoroscopy guided renal pelvic puncture |
| topic | kidneys simulator percutaneous access training puncture fluoroscopy |
| url | https://www.urovest.ru/jour/article/view/753 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT nkgadzhiev comparativeevaluationofsimulatorsforpractisingfluoroscopyguidedrenalpelvicpuncture AT dsgorelov comparativeevaluationofsimulatorsforpractisingfluoroscopyguidedrenalpelvicpuncture AT aamishchenko comparativeevaluationofsimulatorsforpractisingfluoroscopyguidedrenalpelvicpuncture AT vpbritov comparativeevaluationofsimulatorsforpractisingfluoroscopyguidedrenalpelvicpuncture AT rrkharchilava comparativeevaluationofsimulatorsforpractisingfluoroscopyguidedrenalpelvicpuncture AT efsharafutdinov comparativeevaluationofsimulatorsforpractisingfluoroscopyguidedrenalpelvicpuncture AT sbpetrov comparativeevaluationofsimulatorsforpractisingfluoroscopyguidedrenalpelvicpuncture AT ddshkarupa comparativeevaluationofsimulatorsforpractisingfluoroscopyguidedrenalpelvicpuncture |