A Critique of the Interaction of Two Major Sects with Narrations of the Excellences of Suras (Chapters) Based on the Rule of Tolerance in the Evidence of Traditions
One of the most frequent rules in various areas of demonstrative jurisprudence of Two Major Sects of Islam religion is a rule that is known among Shīʿa as “tolerance in the evidence of traditions” (Arabic: التسامح فی أدلّة السنن) and in Sunnī as “latitudinarianism in documents” (Arabic: التساهل فی أ...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | Persian |
| Published: |
Razavi University of Islamic Sciences
2023-07-01
|
| Series: | آموزه‌های قرآنی |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://qd.razavi.ac.ir/article_1631_2d9ff8b694fa98aed7f7828604b61ea0.pdf |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1839608374010839040 |
|---|---|
| author | Sayyid Ali Delbari Alborz Mohaqiq Garfami |
| author_facet | Sayyid Ali Delbari Alborz Mohaqiq Garfami |
| author_sort | Sayyid Ali Delbari |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | One of the most frequent rules in various areas of demonstrative jurisprudence of Two Major Sects of Islam religion is a rule that is known among Shīʿa as “tolerance in the evidence of traditions” (Arabic: التسامح فی أدلّة السنن) and in Sunnī as “latitudinarianism in documents” (Arabic: التساهل فی أسانید). Believers in the general application of this rule have based it for reasons such as consensus (Arabic: إجماع), tradition famous through practice (Arabic: الشهرة العملیّة), and rational judgement (intellectual judgement) and a group of aḥādīth (Arabic: أحادیث, plural form for ḥadīth, literally “talk” or “discourse”) called “Akhbar-e- Man Balagh” (Arabic: أخبار من بلغ). The understanding of the aforementioned narrations and the extent of application of this rule has caused a conflict of opinions among scholars. The narrations containing the excellences of suras of the Holy Book of Quran is one of the fields of application of the rule of tolerance. The present research has explained the types of exposure to this group of narrations based on the rule of tolerance by using descriptive-exploratory method and using library sources and seeks to find a suitable approach about narrations of the excellences of suras (chapters) of the Holy Book of Quran. The interaction with these narrations is organized based on a special reading of the rule of tolerance in the selected approach, which is based on a rational interpretation of the contents of Man-Balagh (Arabic: من بلغ)’s narrations and is compatible with the indications of some verses and traditions. The use of weak narrations containing the excellences of suras (chapters) will be permissible based on this approach considering three conditions and without any certainty of attributing these narrations to Sharʿ (Islamic rules). |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-995644d8078045e5b074b05ac6de6263 |
| institution | Matheson Library |
| issn | 2251-9378 2783-4085 |
| language | fas |
| publishDate | 2023-07-01 |
| publisher | Razavi University of Islamic Sciences |
| record_format | Article |
| series | آموزه‌های قرآنی |
| spelling | doaj-art-995644d8078045e5b074b05ac6de62632025-07-31T10:55:23ZfasRazavi University of Islamic Sciencesآموزه‌های قرآنی2251-93782783-40852023-07-01203712115110.30513/qd.2022.3527.17551631A Critique of the Interaction of Two Major Sects with Narrations of the Excellences of Suras (Chapters) Based on the Rule of Tolerance in the Evidence of TraditionsSayyid Ali Delbari0Alborz Mohaqiq Garfami1Associate professor of Quran & Hadith Studies, Razavi University of Islamic SciencesMA of Quran & Hadith Studies, Razavi University of Islamic SciencesOne of the most frequent rules in various areas of demonstrative jurisprudence of Two Major Sects of Islam religion is a rule that is known among Shīʿa as “tolerance in the evidence of traditions” (Arabic: التسامح فی أدلّة السنن) and in Sunnī as “latitudinarianism in documents” (Arabic: التساهل فی أسانید). Believers in the general application of this rule have based it for reasons such as consensus (Arabic: إجماع), tradition famous through practice (Arabic: الشهرة العملیّة), and rational judgement (intellectual judgement) and a group of aḥādīth (Arabic: أحادیث, plural form for ḥadīth, literally “talk” or “discourse”) called “Akhbar-e- Man Balagh” (Arabic: أخبار من بلغ). The understanding of the aforementioned narrations and the extent of application of this rule has caused a conflict of opinions among scholars. The narrations containing the excellences of suras of the Holy Book of Quran is one of the fields of application of the rule of tolerance. The present research has explained the types of exposure to this group of narrations based on the rule of tolerance by using descriptive-exploratory method and using library sources and seeks to find a suitable approach about narrations of the excellences of suras (chapters) of the Holy Book of Quran. The interaction with these narrations is organized based on a special reading of the rule of tolerance in the selected approach, which is based on a rational interpretation of the contents of Man-Balagh (Arabic: من بلغ)’s narrations and is compatible with the indications of some verses and traditions. The use of weak narrations containing the excellences of suras (chapters) will be permissible based on this approach considering three conditions and without any certainty of attributing these narrations to Sharʿ (Islamic rules).https://qd.razavi.ac.ir/article_1631_2d9ff8b694fa98aed7f7828604b61ea0.pdfḥadīth (news or story)the excellences of suras (chapters)rule of tolerancedocumentvalidation |
| spellingShingle | Sayyid Ali Delbari Alborz Mohaqiq Garfami A Critique of the Interaction of Two Major Sects with Narrations of the Excellences of Suras (Chapters) Based on the Rule of Tolerance in the Evidence of Traditions آموزه‌های قرآنی ḥadīth (news or story) the excellences of suras (chapters) rule of tolerance document validation |
| title | A Critique of the Interaction of Two Major Sects with Narrations of the Excellences of Suras (Chapters) Based on the Rule of Tolerance in the Evidence of Traditions |
| title_full | A Critique of the Interaction of Two Major Sects with Narrations of the Excellences of Suras (Chapters) Based on the Rule of Tolerance in the Evidence of Traditions |
| title_fullStr | A Critique of the Interaction of Two Major Sects with Narrations of the Excellences of Suras (Chapters) Based on the Rule of Tolerance in the Evidence of Traditions |
| title_full_unstemmed | A Critique of the Interaction of Two Major Sects with Narrations of the Excellences of Suras (Chapters) Based on the Rule of Tolerance in the Evidence of Traditions |
| title_short | A Critique of the Interaction of Two Major Sects with Narrations of the Excellences of Suras (Chapters) Based on the Rule of Tolerance in the Evidence of Traditions |
| title_sort | critique of the interaction of two major sects with narrations of the excellences of suras chapters based on the rule of tolerance in the evidence of traditions |
| topic | ḥadīth (news or story) the excellences of suras (chapters) rule of tolerance document validation |
| url | https://qd.razavi.ac.ir/article_1631_2d9ff8b694fa98aed7f7828604b61ea0.pdf |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT sayyidalidelbari acritiqueoftheinteractionoftwomajorsectswithnarrationsoftheexcellencesofsuraschaptersbasedontheruleoftoleranceintheevidenceoftraditions AT alborzmohaqiqgarfami acritiqueoftheinteractionoftwomajorsectswithnarrationsoftheexcellencesofsuraschaptersbasedontheruleoftoleranceintheevidenceoftraditions AT sayyidalidelbari critiqueoftheinteractionoftwomajorsectswithnarrationsoftheexcellencesofsuraschaptersbasedontheruleoftoleranceintheevidenceoftraditions AT alborzmohaqiqgarfami critiqueoftheinteractionoftwomajorsectswithnarrationsoftheexcellencesofsuraschaptersbasedontheruleoftoleranceintheevidenceoftraditions |