The Accuracy of the Uganda National Tuberculosis and Leprosy Program diagnostic algorithm and the World Health Organisation treatment decision algorithms for childhood tuberculosis: A retrospective analysis.
Diagnosing childhood pulmonary tuberculosis (TB) is a challenge. This led the Uganda National Tuberculosis and Leprosy Program (NTLP) to develop a clinical treatment decision algorithm (TDA) for children. However, there is limited data on its accuracy, and how it compares to new World Health Organiz...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Public Library of Science (PLoS)
2025-01-01
|
| Series: | PLOS Global Public Health |
| Online Access: | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgph.0004026 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1839619492193239040 |
|---|---|
| author | Peter J Kitonsa Bernard Kikaire Peter Wambi Annet Nalutaaya Jascent Nakafeero Gertrude Nanyonga Emma Kiconco Deus Atwiine Robert Castro Ernest A Oumo Hellen T Aanyu Mary N Mudiope Ezekiel Mupere Moorine P Sekadde Swomitra Mohanty Adithya Cattamanchi Eric Wobudeya Devan Jaganath |
| author_facet | Peter J Kitonsa Bernard Kikaire Peter Wambi Annet Nalutaaya Jascent Nakafeero Gertrude Nanyonga Emma Kiconco Deus Atwiine Robert Castro Ernest A Oumo Hellen T Aanyu Mary N Mudiope Ezekiel Mupere Moorine P Sekadde Swomitra Mohanty Adithya Cattamanchi Eric Wobudeya Devan Jaganath |
| author_sort | Peter J Kitonsa |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Diagnosing childhood pulmonary tuberculosis (TB) is a challenge. This led the Uganda National Tuberculosis and Leprosy Program (NTLP) to develop a clinical treatment decision algorithm (TDA) for children. However, there is limited data on its accuracy, and how it compares to new World Health Organization (WHO) TB TDAs for children. This study aimed to evaluate and compare the accuracy of the 2017 Uganda NTLP diagnostic algorithm with the 2022 WHO TDAs for TB among children. We analyzed four years of clinical data from children <15 years old in Kampala, Uganda. Children were classified as per National Institutes of Health (NIH) consensus definitions (Confirmed, Unconfirmed or Unlikely TB). We applied the 2017 Uganda NTLP and 2022 WHO algorithms (A with chest x-ray [CXR], B without CXR) to make a decision to treat for TB or not, and calculated the sensitivity, specificity and predictive values in reference to Confirmed vs. Unlikely TB, as well as a microbiological and composite reference standard. Of the 699 children included in this analysis, 64% (451/699) were under 5 years, 53% (373/669) were male, 12% (85/699) were Xpert Ultra positive, 11% (74/669) were HIV positive and 6% had severe acute malnutrition (SAM). The Uganda NTLP algorithm had a sensitivity of 97.9% (95% CI: 96.4-99.4) and specificity of 25.9% (95% CI: 21.2-30.7). If CXR was considered unavailable, sensitivity was 97.9% (95% CI: 96.4-99.4) and specificity 28.1% (95% CI: 23.2-33.0). In comparison, WHO TDAs had similar sensitivity to the Uganda NTLP, but algorithm A was more specific (32.2%, 95% CI: 26.9-37.5) and algorithm B was less specific (15.4%, 95% CI: 11.3-19.5). The WHO TDAs had better specificity than the NTLP algorithm with CXR, and worse specificity without CXR. Further optimization of the algorithms is needed to improve specificity and reduce over-treatment of TB in children. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-4fd55db53cb84f66b2cf4c0b10ea337f |
| institution | Matheson Library |
| issn | 2767-3375 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2025-01-01 |
| publisher | Public Library of Science (PLoS) |
| record_format | Article |
| series | PLOS Global Public Health |
| spelling | doaj-art-4fd55db53cb84f66b2cf4c0b10ea337f2025-07-23T05:46:10ZengPublic Library of Science (PLoS)PLOS Global Public Health2767-33752025-01-0154e000402610.1371/journal.pgph.0004026The Accuracy of the Uganda National Tuberculosis and Leprosy Program diagnostic algorithm and the World Health Organisation treatment decision algorithms for childhood tuberculosis: A retrospective analysis.Peter J KitonsaBernard KikairePeter WambiAnnet NalutaayaJascent NakafeeroGertrude NanyongaEmma KiconcoDeus AtwiineRobert CastroErnest A OumoHellen T AanyuMary N MudiopeEzekiel MupereMoorine P SekaddeSwomitra MohantyAdithya CattamanchiEric WobudeyaDevan JaganathDiagnosing childhood pulmonary tuberculosis (TB) is a challenge. This led the Uganda National Tuberculosis and Leprosy Program (NTLP) to develop a clinical treatment decision algorithm (TDA) for children. However, there is limited data on its accuracy, and how it compares to new World Health Organization (WHO) TB TDAs for children. This study aimed to evaluate and compare the accuracy of the 2017 Uganda NTLP diagnostic algorithm with the 2022 WHO TDAs for TB among children. We analyzed four years of clinical data from children <15 years old in Kampala, Uganda. Children were classified as per National Institutes of Health (NIH) consensus definitions (Confirmed, Unconfirmed or Unlikely TB). We applied the 2017 Uganda NTLP and 2022 WHO algorithms (A with chest x-ray [CXR], B without CXR) to make a decision to treat for TB or not, and calculated the sensitivity, specificity and predictive values in reference to Confirmed vs. Unlikely TB, as well as a microbiological and composite reference standard. Of the 699 children included in this analysis, 64% (451/699) were under 5 years, 53% (373/669) were male, 12% (85/699) were Xpert Ultra positive, 11% (74/669) were HIV positive and 6% had severe acute malnutrition (SAM). The Uganda NTLP algorithm had a sensitivity of 97.9% (95% CI: 96.4-99.4) and specificity of 25.9% (95% CI: 21.2-30.7). If CXR was considered unavailable, sensitivity was 97.9% (95% CI: 96.4-99.4) and specificity 28.1% (95% CI: 23.2-33.0). In comparison, WHO TDAs had similar sensitivity to the Uganda NTLP, but algorithm A was more specific (32.2%, 95% CI: 26.9-37.5) and algorithm B was less specific (15.4%, 95% CI: 11.3-19.5). The WHO TDAs had better specificity than the NTLP algorithm with CXR, and worse specificity without CXR. Further optimization of the algorithms is needed to improve specificity and reduce over-treatment of TB in children.https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgph.0004026 |
| spellingShingle | Peter J Kitonsa Bernard Kikaire Peter Wambi Annet Nalutaaya Jascent Nakafeero Gertrude Nanyonga Emma Kiconco Deus Atwiine Robert Castro Ernest A Oumo Hellen T Aanyu Mary N Mudiope Ezekiel Mupere Moorine P Sekadde Swomitra Mohanty Adithya Cattamanchi Eric Wobudeya Devan Jaganath The Accuracy of the Uganda National Tuberculosis and Leprosy Program diagnostic algorithm and the World Health Organisation treatment decision algorithms for childhood tuberculosis: A retrospective analysis. PLOS Global Public Health |
| title | The Accuracy of the Uganda National Tuberculosis and Leprosy Program diagnostic algorithm and the World Health Organisation treatment decision algorithms for childhood tuberculosis: A retrospective analysis. |
| title_full | The Accuracy of the Uganda National Tuberculosis and Leprosy Program diagnostic algorithm and the World Health Organisation treatment decision algorithms for childhood tuberculosis: A retrospective analysis. |
| title_fullStr | The Accuracy of the Uganda National Tuberculosis and Leprosy Program diagnostic algorithm and the World Health Organisation treatment decision algorithms for childhood tuberculosis: A retrospective analysis. |
| title_full_unstemmed | The Accuracy of the Uganda National Tuberculosis and Leprosy Program diagnostic algorithm and the World Health Organisation treatment decision algorithms for childhood tuberculosis: A retrospective analysis. |
| title_short | The Accuracy of the Uganda National Tuberculosis and Leprosy Program diagnostic algorithm and the World Health Organisation treatment decision algorithms for childhood tuberculosis: A retrospective analysis. |
| title_sort | accuracy of the uganda national tuberculosis and leprosy program diagnostic algorithm and the world health organisation treatment decision algorithms for childhood tuberculosis a retrospective analysis |
| url | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgph.0004026 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT peterjkitonsa theaccuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT bernardkikaire theaccuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT peterwambi theaccuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT annetnalutaaya theaccuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT jascentnakafeero theaccuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT gertrudenanyonga theaccuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT emmakiconco theaccuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT deusatwiine theaccuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT robertcastro theaccuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT ernestaoumo theaccuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT hellentaanyu theaccuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT marynmudiope theaccuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT ezekielmupere theaccuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT moorinepsekadde theaccuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT swomitramohanty theaccuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT adithyacattamanchi theaccuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT ericwobudeya theaccuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT devanjaganath theaccuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT peterjkitonsa accuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT bernardkikaire accuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT peterwambi accuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT annetnalutaaya accuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT jascentnakafeero accuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT gertrudenanyonga accuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT emmakiconco accuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT deusatwiine accuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT robertcastro accuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT ernestaoumo accuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT hellentaanyu accuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT marynmudiope accuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT ezekielmupere accuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT moorinepsekadde accuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT swomitramohanty accuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT adithyacattamanchi accuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT ericwobudeya accuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis AT devanjaganath accuracyoftheugandanationaltuberculosisandleprosyprogramdiagnosticalgorithmandtheworldhealthorganisationtreatmentdecisionalgorithmsforchildhoodtuberculosisaretrospectiveanalysis |